Henry VIII and Henry VII
National Portrait Gallery, London
This work is connected to Hans Holbein the Younger's dynastic wall painting of 1537 for the Privy Chamber of Whitehall Palace, a mural that showed Henry VIII beside his father Henry VII, together with Henry VIII's mother Elizabeth of York and his third queen, Jane Seymour[1]. The mural asserted the Tudor dynasty's legitimacy through a Latin inscription that openly debated whether father or son had achieved more, crediting Henry VII with bringing peace after civil war and Henry VIII with religious reform, and it became one of the most reproduced images of Henry VIII, copied repeatedly and sent abroad to accompany marriage negotiations[1]. The original mural was destroyed when Whitehall Palace burned down in 1698, and today the only record of its full composition is a smaller painted copy in the Royal Collection; part of Holbein's own preparatory cartoon for the left-hand side, showing Henry VII and Henry VIII, survives separately and is now held by the National Portrait Gallery[1]. That cartoon was assembled from twenty-five separate pieces of paper, with the figures cut out and pasted onto the background before the background itself was cut away, evidence of a working method built for transfer onto a wall rather than for display as a finished drawing in its own right[1]. Henry VIII reportedly took little sustained interest in Holbein's work at court until this composition and the related Ambassadors, after which the king's use of Holbein for portraiture became more consistent[1].
Where it is held
Held at National Portrait Gallery, London, United Kingdom.
The surviving preparatory cartoon for the left-hand portion of the mural is held by the National Portrait Gallery, London. The only record of the complete mural composition is a later copy held in the Royal Collection. The original wall painting was destroyed with Whitehall Palace in the fire of 1698[1].
A mural built to argue for a dynasty
Holbein's 1537 wall painting for the Privy Chamber at Whitehall did more than record likenesses. Its Latin inscription staged an explicit comparison between father and son, asking whether Henry VII, who had brought peace after years of civil conflict, or Henry VIII, credited in the text with religious reform and removing unworthy men from power, deserved the greater honour[1]. The room itself was not a public gallery. It was a semi-private chamber, fitted with a crystal fountain and an elaborate French fireplace, where the king dined and received visitors, meaning the mural's argument for Tudor legitimacy was aimed at exactly the audience with the standing to matter.
Assembled to be transferred, not admired
The surviving cartoon for the left-hand portion of the composition, now at the National Portrait Gallery, reveals Holbein's practical working method rather than a polished finished drawing. It was built from twenty-five separate pieces of paper: individual figures were drawn, cut out, and pasted onto a background sheet, which was then itself cut away around them, apparently to avoid doubling the paper's thickness once the whole assembly was pricked through with tiny holes to transfer the outlines onto the wall[1]. Not every part of the cartoon was pricked in this way. The architectural elements were left unpricked, suggesting the right-hand side of the composition, now lost, may have been copied directly from the left rather than separately transferred, a shortcut visible elsewhere in Holbein's design practice[1].
A face that changed after a death
A related small panel version of Henry VIII's head shows one telling difference from the cartoon: the king is shown fully frontal rather than in the three-quarter view used in the original composition[1]. That change has been linked to timing. Jane Seymour, shown in the mural as Henry's living queen, may have died during the painting's execution or even before the commission properly began, and once she was no longer alive, Henry became the only living figure represented in a composition otherwise built around dead ancestors. Substituting a full-face head for the original three-quarter view was, on this reading, a practical adjustment made to the working cartoon rather than a decision requiring an entirely new sitting from the king himself[1].
Common questions
Does the original Whitehall mural still exist?
No. It was destroyed when Whitehall Palace burned down in 1698. A later painted copy in the Royal Collection is the only surviving record of the full composition, and part of Holbein's own preparatory cartoon survives separately at the National Portrait Gallery.
Why does the mural compare Henry VII and Henry VIII?
Its Latin inscription explicitly debates which king achieved more, crediting Henry VII with bringing peace after civil conflict and Henry VIII with religious reform. The comparison was designed to assert the legitimacy of the Tudor dynasty as a whole.
How was the surviving cartoon made?
It was assembled from twenty-five separate pieces of paper, with individual figures cut out and pasted onto a background, then pricked with tiny holes so the outlines could be transferred directly onto the palace wall.
Did this painting change Holbein's standing with Henry VIII?
It appears to have. Henry reportedly showed little sustained interest in Holbein's work before this composition and the related Ambassadors, after which Holbein's use for royal portraiture, including painting Henry's prospective brides, became more consistent.
Sources
Editorial draws on the following references, verified against the museum and public-domain image record for this work.
- [1] book Foister, Susan, 1954-, Holbein in England Used for: this artwork.
Editorial overseen by Solis Prints. Sources verified 2026-09-03. Click a source for details, or hover over [N] in the page above to preview.
Editorial standardsMethodologyCorrectionsAI disclosureAbout the editorial team
Take it home.
More prints by Hans Holbein the Younger →